Skip to content

Altered and Diluted

Federal government envisions making hospital reforms tangible through an adjustment act, facing opposition from some quarters due to numerous exceptions in the proposed legislation.

Altered and softened
Altered and softened

Altered and Diluted

The healthcare reform, approved by the Bundesrat last November, is set to face further developments as the Bundestag considers passing the bill by the end of the year. However, the postponement of the reform until 2028 has raised concerns regarding the financial stability of health insurance companies.

Primary concerns include rising medical costs across insurance lines, leading to potential service cuts and reduced coverage options. Rising health insurance premiums, projected to increase around 7% in 2025, are another pressing issue, driven by inflation, drug prices, and demographic shifts.

The expiration of Affordable Care Act (ACA) subsidies poses a significant risk, potentially leading to insurance market destabilization and increased uninsured rates. Worsening provider workforce shortages and hospital financial pressures, exacerbated by uncompensated care from uninsured patients, are also major concerns.

Potential solutions to mitigate this financial crisis involve both policy and operational reforms. Restoring or extending ACA subsidies could help stabilize insurance markets and prevent premium spikes. Implementing drug price reforms could curb rising pharmaceutical costs contributing to premium increases.

Encouraging consolidation and efficiency in healthcare delivery, while addressing workforce shortages, could help control costs. Leveraging technology, including AI, to optimize care management and control provider expenses, is another potential solution, though its use must be balanced with regulatory oversight.

Insurers reconfiguring their business models, such as UnitedHealth paring down Medicare Advantage segments to restore profitability while preparing for long-term market stability, is also a proposed solution. State and local governmental involvement to plan for uninsured population surges and support provider infrastructure amid financial strain is another important aspect.

Critics argue that exceptions in the current draft adaptation law could threaten patient safety, potentially hindering the intended specialization and concentration. The dispute over the federal criteria for the states' approach remains unresolved, leading to special regulations in the draft that benefit the states.

The statutory health insurance companies will not bear the transformation costs, a point of concern for the Left faction, who warn that hospitals must be reimbursed for their actual costs. The immediate costs for the transformation have been spared in the law, a decision that pleases statutory health insurance, which aims for quality as a counter-performance for the money of its contributors in the long run.

States can grant permanent exceptions for certain indispensable hospitals, which could lead to patients being treated in hospitals below general quality standards. This aspect has been criticized by the Greens, who also voice concerns about the watering down of quality criteria in the reform.

The cabinet draft of the law is expected to be completed in September, providing further clarity on the future of Germany's healthcare system.

Read also:

Latest